Guidelines for Examination
PART C
CHAPTER IV PATENTABILITY
9. Inventive step
9.8 Problem-and-solution approach
9.8.1 Determination of the closest prior art
 

HOME

E  /  D   /  F

 

 
 
PART C
CHAPTER IV PATENTABILITYCHAPTER IV PATENTABILITY
9. Inventive step9. Inventive step
9.8 Problem-and-solution approach9.8 Problem-and-solution approach
       9.8.2 Formulation of the objective technical problem9.8.2 Formulation of the objective technical problem  
 

9.8.1

Determination of the closest prior art

 

The closest prior art is that combination of features, disclosed in one single reference, which constitutes the most promising starting point for an obvious development leading to the invention. In selecting the closest prior art, the first consideration is that it should be directed to a similar purpose or effect as the invention or at least belong to the same or a closely related technical field as the claimed invention. In practice, the closest prior art is generally that which corresponds to a similar use and requires the minimum of structural and functional modifications to arrive at the claimed invention (T 606/89, not published in OJ).

 

The closest prior art must be assessed from the skilled person's point of view on the day before the filing or priority date valid for the claimed invention.

 

In identifying the closest prior art, account should be taken of what the applicant himself acknowledges in his description and claims to be known. Any such acknowledgement of known art should be regarded by the examiner as being correct, unless the applicant states he has made a mistake (see VI, 8.5).