Guidelines for Examination
PART C
CHAPTER III CLAIMS
4. Clarity and interpretation of claims
4.12 Negative limitations (e.g. disclaimers)
 

HOME

E  /  D   /  F

 

 
 
PART C
CHAPTER III CLAIMSCHAPTER III CLAIMS
4. Clarity and interpretation of claims4. Clarity and interpretation of claims
  4.11 Reference signs4.11 Reference signs     4.13 Comprising vs. consisting4.13 Comprising vs. consisting  
 

4.12

Negative limitations (e.g. disclaimers)

 

A claim's subject-matter is normally defined in terms of positive features indicating that certain technical elements are present. Exceptionally, however, the subject-matter may be restricted using a negative limitation expressly stating that particular features are absent. This may be done e.g. to remove non-patentable embodiments disclosed in the application as filed (see T 4/80, OJ 4/1982, 149) or if the absence of a feature can be deduced from the application as filed (see T 278/88, not published in OJ).

 

Negative limitations such as disclaimers may be used only if adding positive features to the claim either would not define more clearly and concisely the subject-matter still protectable (see T 4/80, OJ 4/1982, 149) or would unduly limit the scope of the claim (see T 1050/93, not published in OJ).

 

With respect to the allowability of a disclaimer not disclosed in the application as filed, see VI, 5.3.11.