Guidelines for Examination
PART E
CHAPTER XI APPEALS
7. Interlocutory revision
7.3 Reimbursement of appeal fees
 

HOME

E  /  D   /  F

 

 
 
PART E
CHAPTER XI APPEALSCHAPTER XI APPEALS
7. Interlocutory revision7. Interlocutory revision
  7.2 Remittal to the Board of Appeal7.2 Remittal to the Board of Appeal       
 

7.3

Reimbursement of appeal fees

 

In the event of interlocutory revision, reimbursement of appeal fees will be ordered by the department whose decision has been impugned if such reimbursement is equitable by reason of a substantial procedural violation. This is particularly the case when essential facts or evidence were not taken into consideration in arriving at a decision, e.g. where a document filed at the EPO in good time by the party concerned is not placed in the file before a decision is reached or where the decision is based on facts or evidence on which the party concerned had no opportunity of presenting his comments.

 

Rule 67

Art. 109



If the decision is rectified by an interlocutory revision not because of any substantial procedural violation but e.g. because the party concerned submits amendments at the time of filing the appeal, there will be no reimbursement of appeal fees.

 

If the department whose decision is contested considers the requirements of Art. 109 for interlocutory revision to be fulfilled, but not the requirements of Rule 67 for reimbursement of the appeal fee, it must rectify its decision and remit the request for reimbursement of the appeal fee to the board of appeal for a decision (see J 32/95, OJ 12/1999, 713).